Geoffrey is actually killed inside a biking collision when you look at the 1186 and you can Constance married (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, cuatro th Earl regarding Chester, towards 3 rd February 1188, in the a marriage put up by King Henry 11. Which marriage deteriorated and you will Ranulph imprisoned Constance inside the 1196. Rebellions was sparked round the Brittany on the and you can Ranulph released their from inside the 1198. Back into Brittany, Constance had their relationship annulled and later during the 1198, she grabbed Man de- Trips due to the fact their ‘second’ spouse.
Constance died aged forty, (possibly of leprosy, maybe following childbirth so you’re able to dual girls) into the 5 th September 1201 on Nantes
Although this wasn’t a consanguineous relationship however, certainly affinity, one basic-knowledge dating would have rendered relationship between Constance and any one of John’s brothers impossible in the place of a dispensation –– and that because of the party’s rating would have had to are from this new pope himself
The concept you to Constance had an affair having John adopting the death of Geoffrey and you can just before John’s relationship so you’re able to Isabella out-of Gloucester within the 1189, hence she are mommy so you’re able to Joanna is extremely contentious and keeps provoked much discussion contained in this genealogical groups.
One to feedback of an excellent genealogist states you to definitely ‘this new journal ‘The newest Plantagenet Connection’ possess typed an ahnentafel from E Plantagenet, partner away from Henry V11, gives Joanna’s mother’s identity as Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess away from Brittany. This is the Constance who was simply John’s sis-in-law! Considering the well-understood animosity between John and Constance along with Д°zlandaca bayanla evlen her own tries to force their child Arthur’s welfare as much as the fresh new throne away from The united kingdomt was concerned (and we also most of the recognize how disastrously you to proved!), I truly get the recommended relationships a little hard to swallow. This new Constance one to history illustrates will not strike me personally just like the on who John could easily coerce into sleep.’
‘ A concept who identify Joanna’s mother since the Constance does not take into account an extremely crucial point in canon legislation. Who signify particular shadow of the count have to seriously have come right down to united states, if this inside brand new ask for it, the new deliberations, or even the actual dispensation by itself. As far as i are alert, little of the type can be found.’
Of the just with sex with John, not to mention results him a child, Constance will have based a primary-training dating away from attraction with John’s sisters –– along with John’s sis Geoffrey
My own view for what it’s really worth, is that had Constance been the mother away from Joanna she would surely possess produced their unique up within her house along with her title would-be too called Constance’s almost every other college students because of the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Housemaid out of Brittany, Matilda/Maud away from Brittany and Arthur).
Agatha was born regarding 1168 within the Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It is infamous you to she is a mistress out-of John and many nearest and dearest woods bring their own, even if solitary, because the mom out-of Joanna. Extremely genealogists yet not believe that it’s simply conjecture one to the woman is Joanna’s mom due to the fact zero evidence otherwise facts exist to demonstrate so it.
One provider apparently considering try Sir William Dugdale, regarding the Baronage out-of The united kingdomt (1675-6). He states his supply are Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation for Wales’ (1584). Powell’s work is an expanded model of H Lloyd’s translation off ‘The brand new Historie regarding Cambria’ by the twelve th century Saint Caradoc out of Llancarfan. A new source, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ from the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 along with labels Agatha de- Ferrers, child off Robert de- Ferrers, last Earl from derby, since Joanna’s mom.
Even when she can’t be totally dismissed since the an applicant for mom off Joanna, undoubtedly there would be particular shade away from their own from inside the an effective chronicle and other historical site, when the she had in reality come the mother of the partner off the brand new Prince out-of Northern Wales.